The opposite of a data center is the church
On data centers, communism, and the church — what each claims to be, versus its corrupted twin
The data centers are designed to suck the resources of the land dry and leave its people behind. The church's aim is to rejuvenate the land and fulfil the people in it.
Data centers — shared concern, refused conclusion
I'm not someone who sees the evil data center as a simple question. I accept the environmental and economic critique in full — the water, the electricity, the billionaire greed underneath it — and I don't ask anyone to abandon that critique.
What I won't accept is the jump from "this is a real problem" to "therefore destroy it." Not because destruction is unthinkable, but because destroying something without a better, fully designed replacement already in hand is hopeless. You're fucking hopeless if you have no alternative.
I'm not the opponent of the person who hates data centers. I'm hoping to recruit exactly that person's energy toward a different target — the person who already feels the resource-cost most sharply is the one best positioned to help design the actual solution, not just the one best positioned to tear a thing down.
Communism — they want the revolution, I want the solution
I won't dismantle the case for revolution. I accept the appeal, the intellect, the emotional truth behind Marx's diagnosis of bourgeoisie exploitation — there's no shortage of genius in it.
But I won't fight for it anyway, ever. A revolution's own stated method, in Marx's words, is that its ends "can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions." A revolution is a demand for a pile of rubble first, with the plan for what comes after left as a distant, unspecified promise. The delete key is only one key on a keyboard — erasing is the cheap, single-decision move; building is thousands of individual decisions.
I picture a riot as angry 14-year-olds in ski masks — not a judgment on the cause behind a protest, but on the specific moment a brick goes through a shopkeeper's window. You're no longer the cause at that point — you're just left with broken glass. I care about the reality after the fire settles: are you breathing clean air, is there peace — not whether the symbolic act felt righteous in the moment.
I agree that dictatorship — controlling how people's hearts are allowed to bleed — is the enemy. But Marxism's own method, erase first and design the replacement later, is the same mistake dictators make, just pointed a different direction. You wish to erase that which you don't like. I wish to replace it. If you want to revolutionise your house, you shouldn't bring it to the ground; if you want a new house, go build a new house.
I won't even give my sweat to go to the gym sometimes. I can't hold myself to small, chosen disciplines consistently, so I refuse to pretend I could give my life to an abstract revolution whose first and only guaranteed step is destruction. I'll give my life only to something I could stand inside afterward without wanting to look away from my own hands.
A communist I spoke to on campus wanted a revolution to share her own privilege more widely. My answer: if you want to share something you like, you don't destroy it and replace it — you reproduce it. We agree on the goal. We disagree only on the conclusion.
I don't want the revolution, I don't want the solution — I want the evolution. Not a static fixed endpoint arrived at once, but continuous, non-destructive change. It still carries everything "solution" was pointing at — something beautiful, something worth building — just named more accurately as a process.
The church — the corrupted twin of the data center
The mega-church and the data center share the same shape: both claim usefulness — technological progress, spiritual community — while structurally sucking up resources, electricity and water on one side, money on the other, rather than serving the people around them. "The love of money" is the fault line (1 Timothy 6:10, not money itself) — a church that loves money more than Jesus has, by definition, stopped being a church. This is one specific corrupted brand, not an indictment of the church as a category. I'm willing to accept good examples and bad examples.
A true church rejuvenates the people and the surrounding community — a pillar, not an extraction mechanism. Even if you don't believe in God: replace "God" with "that which is worth building" and the claim still stands — a church is the definition of something worth building; if it's not worth building, it's not a church.
I want to say something painful here. I want to love Jesus, and I'm a hypocrite — I've never been to church. I'm not resolving that tension in this essay, only naming it honestly.
This essay is addressed to four kinds of reader at once — hate data centers and love God, hate data centers and hate God, love data centers and hate God, or something in between — each of you: this is the essay for you. I don't ask you to resolve your disagreement with me about God before engaging. Where I disagree, I say so plainly. But I do not find you revolting.
The synthesis
Holding up a peace placard to the Nazis would, paradoxically, have been the choice for pain, not against it — Britain's actual war was fought in the name of peace. "Evolution not revolution" isn't naive pacifism. Sometimes the cost of real peace is high — but the goal, peace and not rubble, is what decides whether an action is justified, not the willingness to cause pain in service of it.
You don't get to demolish a house people are living in unless you already have a fully designed, demonstrably better replacement — all the burden is on the solution. Communism fails this test: revolution first, design later. A mega-church fails this test in miniature: it claims usefulness it doesn't deliver. A data center is not yet failing or passing this test — it's the live, open case, which is exactly why I stay in dialogue with people who hate it rather than defend it outright.
Quotes
- “They want the revolution, I want the solution.”
- “I don't want the revolution, I don't want the solution — I want the evolution.”
- “You're fucking hopeless if you have no alternative.”
- “The delete key is only one key on a keyboard.”
- “If you want to share something you like, you don't destroy it and replace it — you reproduce it.”
- “I do not find you revolting. I do not find data centers revolting.”